The Legal Examiner Mark The Legal Examiner Mark The Legal Examiner Mark search twitter facebook feed linkedin instagram google-plus avvo phone envelope checkmark mail-reply spinner error close
Skip to main content

Monsanto is encouraging farmers to ask for the deregulation of genetically engineered alfalfa. They are telling them that it is their right to choose biotechnology. This grand effort is in the face of proven evidence that Monsanto’s Roundup Ready™ Alfalfa contaminates conventional alfalfa—and wild alfalfa species along roadsides and rivers, increases weed resistance, and fails to improve yield. Alfalfa is the feed of choice for organic dairies and ranches. What happens when contaminated alfalfa gets into our food supply? Many organic choices may cease to exist. So I ask, what of our consumer right to protect our food supply? And the farmer’s right to uncontaminated seed? What do we do when "their right to choose biotechnology" interferes with the rights of many to safe food and sustainable farming?

For one, we speak up! The U.S. government’s site will accept comments submitted by 11:59 p.m. Eastern Standard Time tonight (3/3/10). There is a handful of hours left to get your concerns heard. When the clock strikes midnight (or 9 p.m. PST, 11p.m CST and 7p.m HAST), it’ll be too late. Instead of your carriage turning into a pumpkin, the patented DNA of two different strains of Roundup Ready™ Alfalfa may be on their way to commercial release into our food supply and environment.

And speak up where it counts! Direct comments are the only ones assured of consideration. There are many environmental groups encouraging people to comment through pre-written letters. They are great to gather more information and perspective. However, the USDA instructs commenters to "not use alternative means to send comments through the Internet."

What is Roundup Ready™ Alfalfa and why is it of great concern? This is a seed that has been developed through biotechnology to be resistant to high doses of the broad based herbicide Round Up™. The active ingredient in Round Up™ is Glyphosate. Monsanto owns both the Roundup Ready Alfalfa seeds and the herbicide. It is very profitable for them to sell and contract their patented seeds to farmers as it facilitates a circle of dependence.

The alfalfa is of great concern because of its prevalence, its dependency on pollinators and its wide usage as feed for organic dairy and cattle. Alfalfa grows wild as well as being an intentional crop, so is at greater risk of widespread contamination. The USDA’s own Environmental Impact Statement reveals significant cross contamination occurrences. They are now proposing that they can restrict the GE crops for protection. However, the several varieties of bees that pollinate the alfalfa travel for many miles. Their solutions are unrealistic. Please read more about What is Wrong with Round Up Ready Alfalfa? from the Geerston Seed Farms and also this informative blog from Nourished Kitchen.


  1. Gravatar for Elizabeth Lerman-Kling
    Elizabeth Lerman-Kling

    For time's sake,I left out a lot of info. Alfalfa is also a perennial crop, which increases the risk of GMO contamination. The over use of Glyphosate is causing many environmental and agricultural problems.

    A less talked about concern, is that it kills off the wild plants that Monarch butterflies need to subside. The Monarch butterfly population has been alarmingly decreasing. Glyphosate (i.e, RoundUp)use is a contributing factor to their decline and endangerment.

    More known, is the increased weed resistance which is a large impedance to sustainable agriculture. There are several recent news stories on this. Also, glyphosate does not wash off of produce and it carries toxicity to the environment and those consuming it. There are detectable levels of this herbicide in many of our foods.

  2. Gravatar for Jane Akre

    Elizabeth- Thanks so much for this heads up! There is absolutely no assurance [ from the likes of a company such as Monsanto] as to the safety of this risky technology, and once it is released into the fields, it is irretrievable.

    We are looking at a future disaster by investing in agricultural biotechnology- IMHO.

  3. Gravatar for Elizabeth Lerman-Kling
    Elizabeth Lerman-Kling

    Thanks Jane! You are absolutely right. My regrets for not getting this out sooner. The comment period on glyphosate-tolerant alfalfa will be ending in 18 minutes. I'm unsure of the USDA's decision process from there. They were forced to further investigate the concerns of this alfalfa because of lawsuits.

    From my understanding of the EIS there really is not a realistic solution to protect the farmers growing organic and conventional alfalfa from GMO contamination, nor the final food products.

    Last chance for comments on this:

  4. Gravatar for April Reeves

    I'm curious as to why the USDA suggests not to use alternate sources: is it because they don't want this awareness spread around, or are they collecting accurate numbers to understand just how big a fight they will have on their hands. Call me a skeptic, but I can't believe they are asking for that with good intentions.

    Thank you so much for this post! Hopefully people will come to understand that their entire food system is being hijacked by Multi-National corporations that do not have the public's best interests at heart.

    This is a tipping point in history: do we allow this and take what could follow (world food domination, higher prices for everything you eat, world control through food, a complete alteration of every plant and animal on earth) or do we work collectively, every small organization to every large continent?

    Not on my watch...

Comments are closed.