Legal Examiner Voices


Email American Association for Justice American Association for Justice on Twitter American Association for Justice on Facebook
American Association for Justice
American Association for Justice
Contributor •

Airman Colton Read Tragedy Highlights Need to Pass Carmelo Rodriguez Military Medical Accountability Act


On Thursday, July 9, Airman Colton Read checked into the Travis Air Force Base’s David Grant Medical Center in Fairfield, Calif., for what he was told would be a routine operation on his gallbladder. But after hours of surgery, Airman Read awoke in the UC Davis Medical Center to find that both of his legs had been amputated.

About an hour into the procedure, a relatively inexperienced doctor accidently nicked his aorta, leading to massive blood loss. For nine hours, the staff at the base’s medical center scrambled to repair the damage done to Airman Read. Finally, they acknowledged that his injuries required specialized care and transferred him to UC Davis Medical Center.

Airman Read’s family says that the doctors on the base admitted that they had made a mistake, but did not explain why it took them nine hours to transfer him to a superior hospital. Terry DeBrow, Read’s grandmother told the Dallas Morning News that had he gotten to UC Davis Medial Center earlier, “He might have had some therapy to deal with, but he would have his legs.”

Unfortunately for Airman Read and his family, the law does not allow him to file a medical negligence claim for his treatment on the base. A 1950 Supreme Court decision in United States v. Feres stated that the government could not be sued for injuries sustained by active-duty servicemen and women. This decision also barred soldiers from filing suit for injuries not related to combat, such as Airman Read’s.

Currently there is legislation under consideration by Congress that would restore the rights of the men and women of our military to hold negligent care providers accountable. The Carmelo Rodriguez Military Medical Accountability Act (S. 1347 / H.R. 1478), sponsored by Rep. Maurice D. Hinchey (D-NY) and Sen. Charles Schumer (D-NY), would ensure that the brave men and women who serve in our armed forces have the ability to receive justice when they are injured by the negligence of others.


Have an opinion about this post? Please consider leaving a comment or subscribing to the feed to have future articles delivered to your feed reader.

  1. Mike Bryant says:
    up arrow

    This is a very important issue and one that involves protecting our troops. Time for the Congress to step up and protect them.

  2. up arrow

    I agree with Mike. Thanks for this thoughtful and well reasoned article!